Fake rate Duplicate rate Pileup rate
A B C A B C A B C
TIB1+TIB2+MTIB3 0.9822 0.9823 0.9824 0.01111 0.01106 0.01103 0.01643 0.01636 0.01634
TIB1+TIB2+MTIB4 0.9894 0.9897 0.9897 0.005544 0.005296 0.005294 0.009916 0.009606 0.009604
TIB1+TIB2+MTID1_pos 0.9824 0.9827 0.9825 0.01071 0.01043 0.01062 0.01616 0.01593 0.01608
TIB1+TIB2+MTID1_neg 0.9775 0.977 0.9771 0.01282 0.01337 0.01321 0.02074 0.02116 0.02109
TID1_pos+TID2_pos+TID3_pos 0.9921 0.992 0.992 0.004424 0.004632 0.004545 0.007238 0.007246 0.007266
TID1_neg+TID2_neg+TID3_neg 0.9935 0.9934 0.9932 0.003643 0.003601 0.003793 0.006197 0.006258 0.00644
TID1_pos+TID2_pos+MTID3_pos 0.978 0.9771 0.9773 0.0167 0.01734 0.01711 0.01986 0.02078 0.02061
TID1_neg+TID2_neg+MTID3_neg 0.9791 0.9778 0.9785 0.0159 0.01705 0.01651 0.01861 0.01978 0.01913
TID1_pos+TID2_pos+MTEC1_pos 0.9911 0.9913 0.9912 0.006254 0.006219 0.006199 0.008208 0.007999 0.008013
TID1_neg+TID2_neg+MTEC1_neg 0.9913 0.9912 0.9913 0.005694 0.005751 0.00561 0.007854 0.007924 0.007787
TID2_pos+TID3_pos+TEC1_pos 0.9886 0.9877 0.9881 0.008131 0.008883 0.00854 0.01019 0.01099 0.01061
TID2_neg+TID3_neg+TEC1_neg 0.9895 0.9884 0.9884 0.007312 0.008142 0.008192 0.009554 0.01049 0.01054
TID2_pos+TID3_pos+MTEC1_pos 0.9855 0.9851 0.9851 0.01174 0.01209 0.01216 0.01312 0.01353 0.01352
TID2_neg+TID3_neg+MTEC1_neg 0.9861 0.9852 0.9852 0.01089 0.01157 0.01156 0.01244 0.01328 0.01321
TEC1_pos+TEC2_pos+TEC3_pos 0.9836 0.9832 0.9832 0.01286 0.01321 0.01321 0.01503 0.01551 0.01542
TEC1_neg+TEC2_neg+TEC3_neg 0.9848 0.9842 0.9844 0.01221 0.01277 0.01264 0.01394 0.01452 0.01432
TEC1_pos+TEC2_pos+MTEC3_pos 0.9791 0.9788 0.9788 0.01079 0.01143 0.01138 0.01919 0.01961 0.01955
TEC1_neg+TEC2_neg+MTEC3_neg 0.9794 0.979 0.9795 0.01154 0.01183 0.01142 0.01915 0.01952 0.01906
TEC1_pos+TEC2_pos+TEC4_pos 0.9952 0.9951 0.9952 0.003031 0.003245 0.003141 0.004528 0.004567 0.004462
TEC1_neg+TEC2_neg+TEC4_neg 0.9956 0.9953 0.9954 0.002744 0.003061 0.003007 0.00407 0.004247 0.004216
TEC1_pos+TEC2_pos+MTEC4_pos 0.9891 0.9887 0.9887 0.007199 0.007724 0.007696 0.009998 0.01043 0.01041
TEC1_neg+TEC2_neg+MTEC4_neg 0.9894 0.9894 0.9896 0.007037 0.006925 0.006819 0.009724 0.009637 0.009479
TEC2_pos+TEC3_pos+TEC4_pos 0.9754 0.9738 0.9743 0.02217 0.02369 0.02327 0.02249 0.02389 0.02347
TEC2_neg+TEC3_neg+TEC4_neg 0.977 0.9751 0.9754 0.02051 0.02231 0.02203 0.02087 0.02269 0.02236
TEC2_pos+TEC3_pos+MTEC4_pos 0.9752 0.9736 0.9738 0.01846 0.01998 0.01977 0.02273 0.02435 0.02411
TEC2_neg+TEC3_neg+MTEC4_neg 0.9757 0.9752 0.9754 0.01775 0.01839 0.01819 0.02233 0.02272 0.0226
TEC2_pos+TEC3_pos+TEC5_pos 0.9947 0.9946 0.9946 0.003381 0.00357 0.003519 0.004903 0.005026 0.004986
TEC2_neg+TEC3_neg+TEC5_neg 0.9944 0.9942 0.9942 0.003211 0.003434 0.003441 0.005156 0.005412 0.005398
TEC2_pos+TEC3_pos+TEC6_pos 0.9943 0.9941 0.9941 0.001547 0.00167 0.001657 0.005357 0.00552 0.00555
TEC2_neg+TEC3_neg+TEC6_neg 0.9947 0.9944 0.9944 0.001493 0.001663 0.001635 0.004895 0.005234 0.005203
TEC3_pos+TEC4_pos+TEC5_pos 0.9616 0.9588 0.9596 0.03201 0.03484 0.03411 0.0354 0.03806 0.03722
TEC3_neg+TEC4_neg+TEC5_neg 0.9627 0.9602 0.9612 0.0299 0.03241 0.03162 0.03389 0.03629 0.03531
TEC3_pos+TEC4_pos+MTEC5_pos 0.9749 0.974 0.9741 0.01778 0.0187 0.01863 0.02304 0.02376 0.02364
TEC3_neg+TEC4_neg+MTEC5_neg 0.9757 0.9743 0.9746 0.01577 0.01701 0.01676 0.02203 0.02338 0.02305
TEC3_pos+TEC5_pos+TEC6_pos 0.9864 0.9857 0.986 0.0117 0.01246 0.01224 0.0125 0.01317 0.01292
TEC3_neg+TEC5_neg+TEC6_neg 0.9879 0.9868 0.9872 0.01025 0.01133 0.011 0.01111 0.01211 0.01178
TEC4_pos+TEC5_pos+TEC6_pos 0.9615 0.9602 0.961 0.03164 0.03362 0.0328 0.0357 0.03683 0.03594
TEC4_neg+TEC5_neg+TEC6_neg 0.9639 0.9607 0.9622 0.02824 0.03146 0.03005 0.03323 0.03611 0.03466
TEC1_pos+TEC2_pos 0.9807 0.9795 0.9798 0.01275 0.01384 0.01359 0.01771 0.01878 0.01849
TEC1_neg+TEC2_neg 0.9807 0.9794 0.9797 0.01261 0.0138 0.01351 0.01768 0.01887 0.01862
TEC2_pos+TEC3_pos 0.9773 0.9759 0.9762 0.01641 0.01788 0.01762 0.02091 0.0223 0.02204
TEC2_neg+TEC3_neg 0.9773 0.9758 0.9762 0.01641 0.01792 0.01751 0.02073 0.02223 0.0218
TEC3_pos+TEC4_pos 0.977 0.9762 0.9764 0.0157 0.01656 0.01635 0.02108 0.02185 0.02161
TEC3_neg+TEC4_neg 0.9776 0.9766 0.9768 0.01511 0.0162 0.01599 0.02026 0.02125 0.02105
TEC4_pos+TEC5_pos 0.9677 0.9664 0.9663 0.02487 0.02683 0.0267 0.0294 0.03097 0.031
TEC4_neg+TEC5_neg 0.9677 0.9653 0.9657 0.02371 0.02616 0.02613 0.02912 0.03156 0.03104
TIB1+TIB2 0.9866 0.9869 0.9869 0.004793 0.00474 0.004724 0.01241 0.01218 0.01218
TID1_pos+TID2_pos 0.9878 0.9876 0.9876 0.008893 0.009015 0.009029 0.01104 0.01127 0.01125
TID1_neg+TID2_neg 0.9877 0.9875 0.9875 0.008673 0.008904 0.008886 0.01111 0.01136 0.01132
TID2_pos+TID3_pos 0.9875 0.9873 0.9874 0.009738 0.009886 0.009796 0.0114 0.0116 0.01152
TID2_neg+TID3_neg 0.9881 0.9877 0.9879 0.00901 0.009318 0.009179 0.0107 0.01108 0.01088
TEC3_pos+TEC5_pos 0.9907 0.9901 0.9903 0.00766 0.008106 0.007964 0.008571 0.009119 0.008922
TEC3_neg+TEC5_neg 0.9908 0.9903 0.9905 0.00735 0.008 0.007822 0.008391 0.008902 0.008667
A: DQM_CKF_TTbarPU
B: DQM_mkFit_TTbarPU-noDNN-baseline
C: DQM_mkFit_TTbarPU-noDNN-fix